Powered By Blogger

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

REVIEW: X-Men: First Class — Hugh Jackman’s Finest Wolverine Performance



Firstly, let’s get this out of the way:  There has never, and probably will never be a Marvel comic book movie that is exactly the same on screen as in the books.  Actually, I can’t think of one comic book movie that is exactly the same as the comics.  So to hold against X-Men: First Class the fact that it isn’t panel by panel, scene by scene, the same as the source material is silly and doing so will cause you to miss out on what is a pretty good movie.

This is the fifth X-Men movie from Fox, and it is the best.  I didn’t think any Fox-made X-Men movie would ever top X2, which is loosely based off of my all time favorite comic book story, ‘God Loves, Man Kills’, but First Class did so and did so well.

The Bryan Singer directed film is a prequel film (yeah, I know… good prequel movies are so hard to come by) that focuses on the building of the relationship between Charles Xavier aka Professor X (played by James McAvoy) and Erik Lensherr aka Magneto (played by Michael Fassbender) and the foundation of both the X-Men and the Brotherhood of Mutants.

This movie does a surprisingly great job of making you feel like you should be rooting for Magneto all throughout to the very end.  This isn’t surprising as Bryan Singer added much of the plot from the script that would had been X-Men Origins: Magneto to this movie.  Michael Fassbender is the stand-out performance of this film, which is saying a lot considering that to play any character as well as Ian McKellen takes some serious chops.  The anger, sadness, and hatred that he brings to the character is truly heartfelt at various moments.  One of the most surprising things about the movie is that there is no one in the cast that disappointed, actually.  I can’t recall one single cringe-inducing moment due to poor acting.  Which brings me to my next point.


Fassbender’s Magneto

Hugh Jackman was tolerable as Wolverine in this movie.  Yes, you read that right.  Hugh Jackman was actually enjoyable to see as Wolverine.  I know I said before that it’s silly to expect a comic book movie to be completely faithful to the source material, but a near hairless (with the exception of his head and face) probably 6 foot tall movie version of the Wolverine character is about the same as making the Hulk purple.  In this movie Jackman is sitting down at a bar and says one line before he is never seen again.  Anymore than that, and I would had been reminded, mid-viewing, how much of a poor casting call it was to recruit the man for the part.


Short, hairy, and badass.

I enjoyed X-Men: First Class so much that I wouldn’t mind them continuing with this cast.  If they keep the quality of directing, acting, and writing up, I will return time and time again to the theater in support.

The FilmDetective Verdict: 8/10

—Kevin Merrill—FilmDetective—